It’s often difficult early on to know whether or not the medical professionals involved were negligent in causing your suffering. Current Concerns in Medical Negligence Secondly – is your story true? Please tell us more about why our advice didn't help. Stay away from words such as “botched” or “killed” when you’re reporting on complaints against health workers. You have suffered injury because the healthcare provider: If you’ve suffered an injury as a result of medical treatment, this may be referred to as a ‘medical accident’ or ‘patient safety incident’. You might have the right to compensation under these schemes without having to go to court. It can, however, be helpful as it may give you more information about what happened. If the negligence lead to an injury, you may have a legal claim. The court will look at a host of factors to determine whether the report is reasonable or not. They may also advise you to take out insurance (‘after-the-event’ insurance) to protect you from the possibility of having to pay the hospital’s costs if you lose the case. If you think you have suffered a misdiagnosis there are a number of steps you can take: Firstly, you can speak to the medical professional who treated you to get an understanding of why the decision was reached. Medical negligence arises from an act or omission by a medical practitioner, which no reasonably competent and careful practitioner would have committed. Your first defence – is your story in the public interest? Your solicitor will discuss the best way to fund your legal claim. Because clinical negligence cases are very complex, your solicitor may ask you to pay for some initial investigations to assess how strong your case is before entering into an agreement. Where a duty of care is breached, liability for negligence may arise. A story about medical negligence can lead to a defamation case in court, or a complaint to the Press Council or the BCCSA, Ampofo-Anti says. The law in some states has a threshold that determines … What would a member of the public who hears those words that you chose, understand you to be alleging about that doctor?” she explains. In addition, the court will investigate how reliable your sources are, she says. Bhekisisa’s editor-in-chief Mia Malan is joined by media lawyer Okyerebea Ampofo-Anti and the community press ombudsman at Media24 George Claassen. These are complicated agreements and your solicitor will advise you about them. Action against Medical Accidents (AvMA)Freedman HouseChristopher Wren Yard117 High StreetCroydonCR0 1QGHelpline: 0845 123 23 52 (Monday to Friday from 10.00am to 3.30pm). Advice can vary depending on where you live. You should see a solicitor specialised in clinical negligence cases. In many low- and middle-income countries, however, the lack of such records and systems is a major obst… However, if you win your case, some solicitors will take off a percentage of your compensation as their success fee. Thank you, your feedback has been submitted. If you think you or a relative has suffered medical negligence at an NHS institution then you can complain to the NHS, but this is not compulsory. Reporting medical negligence – a practical guide. The failure to provide adequate and appropriate care is called a breach of duty. It’s best to take specialist advice as soon as possible after the incident - don’t leave this until the last minute. The idea of hurt is an important consideration in establishing negligence, as the majority of tortious claims for medical negligence that do not succeed fail because they cannot establish that harm has occurred as a direct result of an act or a failure to a… She graduated with a master’s degree in journalism from Columbia University. This means that Court proceedings must be commenced by issuing a claim form at Court within 3 years. Aisha Abdool Karim is a health reporter at Bhekisisa. It’s important to understand that a clinical negligence action is only about claiming compensation. It also covers the ethical and legal issues that journalists should consider when tackling this topic. It will help if you keep a record of everything that’s relevant to your treatment and any paperwork you've got if you've been through the complaints procedure. But occasionally things can go wrong. The other is administered by the Law Society. In the case of children, the 3-year limit doesn’t start to apply until their 18th birthday. Sandland & Bartlett, 2003, Mental Health Law: Policy and Practice, Oxford. The NHSR has a database of information about all claims made against the NHS, including potential claims and 'incidents' where legal action hasn't been started yet but where a patient says they are going to make a claim. make a healthcare professional say sorry to you. NHS care is usually very good and most people don’t have any problems. You can contact an organisation called Action against Medical Accidents (AvMA) for advice about clinical negligence. “If you publish a statement that a doctor has been negligent, that would be seen as a defamatory statement.” That’s because calling a doctor negligent has an impact on their reputation. However for certain sorts of cases involving children, there is still some limited public funding, for example, if children have suffered a birth injury. If you're told that legal action is why your complaint isn't being investigated within a reasonable time-scale, you should get specialist advice -see below. Lastly – make sure you can show that you have taken the necessary steps to put the story together in an ethical way. Report Medical Negligence, Delhi, India. What does it mean to have power of attorney? The solicitors will look at your case to decide if it’s strong enough for them to take it on. Fewer than 2% of the cases handled by the NHSR end up in court. Because clinical negligence cases are so complex to investigate, some solicitors won’t take on a case if it's within a year of running out of time. Remember that taking legal action can be expensive, stressful and time-consuming. The president of the Health Professions Council of South … It will help if you keep a record of everything that’s relevant to your treatment and any paperwo… Different firms of solicitors have different arrangements for their clients to pay for: Some solicitors will deduct a fee called a success fee from your compensation if you win, but some won’t, so it is worth choosing your solicitor carefully. But when the negligence is the cause of harm to a patient, there may be a good case. While medical negligence is usually the legal concept upon which theses kinds of medical malpractice cases hinge (at least from a "legal fault" perspective), negligence on its own isn't enough to form a valid claim. Negligence Basics. If you do not have legal representation, there are a number of law firms that specialise in medical negligence cases. So if you’re thinking about taking legal action, get legal advice from a solicitor specialised in clinical negligence cases. Where you are not aware that you have suffered an injury as a result of the treatment until later, the 3 years will run from the date that you became aware of your injury. The law requires a higher standard of evidence than otherwise, to support an allegation of negligence against a doctor. © Copyright Bhekisisa - Centre for Health Journalism. Read what we're saying about a range of issues. All rights reserved. Registered charity number 279057 VAT number 726 0202 76 Company limited by guarantee. During #FeesMustFall protests, she was the editor-in-chief of the University of Cape Town student newspaper, Varsity, where she learned that quality reporting “helps tell people's stories in a way that drives tangible changes to broken systems”. This doesn’t mean that your treatment was necessarily negligent. She explains: “The fact that [the operation] should have been simple doesn’t prove anything [about the doctor’s conduct].”. Is there anything wrong with this page? When you believe a doctor has been negligent, there are several ways to report the situation, whether you are seeking a legal remedy or you simply want to prevent someone else from going through the same thing. For example, if the case is settled before going to court, this doesn’t count as a ‘win’ and so you may have to pay your solicitor’s fees. She explains: “It shouldn’t be positioned as some kind of stonewalling by them. However, you should always ask to be referred to a clinical negligence specialist. In most cases, publications won’t throw their journalists under the bus. Since April 2013, legal aid to cover clinical negligence claims is no longer available. In South Africa, defamation is the wrongful and intentional publication of a statement that. We use cookies to improve your experience of our website. who can’t take legal action themselves because they don’t have capacity. It is then necessary to inform the Health Professions Council of South Africa and lodge a complaint. These factors include whether the story is balanced, whether the tone of the story is fair. Because proving medical negligence is difficult, your legal representatives will be able to advise you on … Slip & fall, trip & fall, store accidents, accidents at home or a friend's home, or visiting someone. And in case of medical negligence mostly the doctor is the defendant. Your call is likely to be free of charge if you have a phone deal  that includes free calls to landlines - find out more about calling 0845 numbers. Medical Negligence cases in Ireland involve all types of accidents. Our bodies are not your crime scene: A portrait of GBV in South Africa, A local home for a global dream: The Aurum Institute houses HIV, TB & malaria coalition, To gather or not to gather? “Members of the public could choose to avoid them even before they are found guilty in a court process or HPCSA process based on your reportage.”, Journalists should refrain from framing a bad medical outcome as a “routine operation” that nonetheless ended badly for the patient. In hospital, doctors will always inform their patients that even a simple procedure could go wrong. Let us know, Copyright ©2020 Citizens Advice. It is a well-established law in terms of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 and Human Rights Act 1998, that no one, including doctors, enjoys a complete immunity. We’ll take a full account from you of what has happened and will advise you on whether or not we think you have a claim. Be sure to read the small print carefully before you sign. TAKE ACTION: In response to the California Medical Board’s investigation of Dr. Sears and other doctors, several articles have been written exploring the issue of MEDICAL NEGLIGENCE. These are difficult tests to pass, and you’ll need expert advice to work out whether you have a claim. Negligence is predominantly a theory of liability concerning allegations of medical malpractice, making this type of litigation part of the Tort Law. You could also take legal action for compensation if you’re the next of kin of someone: You don’t have to use the NHS complaints procedure before starting legal action but you may find it helpful to use it to find out more about what has happened. insurance to protect you from costs if you lose your case. The court can’t: NHS Resolution (formerly known as the NHS Litigation Authority) usually represents the NHS if you make a claim against them. We recently sat down with Karen Stott, Principal at ADR & Mediation Services, to discuss her upcoming presentations at two of our seminars.Karen shares her knowledge what to consider when preparing medical negligence claims and joint expert reports. If the claim is about a patient who can’t manage their own affairs because of a mental disability, the 3-year period doesn’t apply until (and unless) they recover from their disability. Obtain your medical records from the hospital or doctor's office. Every person in the chain of publication can be held liable in a defamation case. Bhekisisa has teamed up with Media Hack Collective to create a dashboard to track confirmed COVID-19 cases in South Africa. In medical negligence claims… what is a medico-legal liability report? Before joining Bhekisisa, she worked at the Daily Maverick. These are the basic elements of negligence, to prove the case of negligence all these criteria must be satisfied and in cases of medical negligence in India, the ambit of duty of care and proximate cause increases, as there are life involve in this situation. Medical negligence is an act or omission by a doctor in which the care provided was deviated from accepted standards of practice and cause injury or death to the patient. The rest are settled out of court or dropped by the claimant. Find out how to complain about your doctor or health visitor. You may be able to claim medical negligence compensation for negligent treatment by a medical provider under general Australian law. Here at Medical Negligence Assist we pride ourselves on offering free, no-obligation advice and eligibility checks for those who would like to know how to report a doctor’s negligence and claim compensation for the avoidable harm suffered because of clinical negligence. Medical negligence (also called clinical negligence) is the failure to provide you with adequate and appropriate care that results in you suffering harm as a result of this failure. There are special compensation schemes for some injuries and losses. NHS Choices - Information on hospitals, conditions and treatments. There are two recognised panels of specialist clinical negligence solicitors. The webinar was moderated by Bhekisisa’s editor-in-chief, Mia Malan, and the panelists included Ampofo-Anti, Media 24’s press ombudsman, George Claassen, the president of the Health Professions Council of South Africa (HPCSA), Kgosi Letlape, and the Durban-based orthopaedic surgeon, Rinesh Chetty. “The harm is potentially very severe because it could lead to the end of that doctor’s career and it could lead to the end of their business.”, The damage of irresponsible reporting can last long after your story is published, Ampofo-Anti says. Here’s why African leaders should back it, Rape increases your long-term risk of contracting HIV. No comments . Sometimes insurance policies like some house insurance policies include legal expenses cover which could be used to pay for a clinical negligence claim. If your doctor or hospital is not performing up to the medical standard, you can report it to a regulatory board. 27 May 2013. The solicitor will decide if your case has a reasonable chance of success and should be able to give you an idea how much your compensation you might get. For more information, go to www.gov.uk. your treatment was carried out negligently, that is, the care you received fell below medically acceptable standards, and, compensation if you can’t carry out certain activities or hobbies, the cost of any extra care or equipment you may need. But when it comes to doctors and hospitals, responding to media queries isn’t as simple in, Journalists must be mindful about the tone they use to illustrate the health workers’ failure to respond in the article. There are two recognised panels of specialist clinical negligence solicitors. In other words, the doctor neglected or omitted care that resulted in harm to the patient, according to the. This may cost several thousand pounds. The publication will usually take the responsibility for a defamatory story by paying legal fees and other damages awarded against the reporter, Ampofo-Anti says. Medical negligence. If you disagree with their reasoning, you can ask them for a second opinion – although they are not … Civil Liability and Medical Negligence. A medico-legal liability report (also referred to as an ‘Expert Liability Report’) is a report prepared by a medical specialist for use as evidence in legal proceedings, which sets out the medical specialist’s opinion as to certain aspects of the claimant’s claim. Negligence is the breach of a legal duty to care. Citizens Advice is an operating name of the National Association of Citizens Advice Bureaux. Introduction to the Citizens Advice service, Future of advice: our strategic framework 2019-22, More about using the NHS complaints procedure, More about finding a specialist solicitor, Organisations that can help you make a complaint about health services, Help with legal costs - free or affordable help, who has died because of negligent medical treatment. Claim compensation for any injuries or losses suffered which were a direct result the... Compensation under these schemes without having to go to court issues that should! According to the patient arrives at 06:00 and the community press ombudsman at Media24 George Claassen to inform health! In the public can fall into their hands and be harmed may help with. One way to get an expert to comment on the insurers ’ own.! Most up-to-date version of the negligent treatment by a medical provider under general law... General who report on medical negligence law ” Ampofo-Anti explains for negligent treatment by a medical practitioner, no. 2013, legal aid to cover clinical negligence take off a percentage of compensation! First in South Africa Mental health law: Policy and Practice,.. Malan is joined by media lawyer Okyerebea Ampofo-Anti, gives practical, legal tips for reporting on cases of negligence... To report hospital negligence can be a tricky thing will always inform patients. Or omission by a medical provider under general Australian law treatment, you should get COVID-19... Compensation for any injuries or losses who report on medical negligence which were a direct result the! To comment on the insurers ’ own list, India off a percentage of your as. The chain of publication can be a good story with the costs a! Say for example, that your treatment was necessarily negligent as it may give you a of! Almost always in the public interest both these cases, publications won ’ t have choose! T be positioned as some kind of stonewalling by them report medical negligence claim should always ask to be to. Part of the negligent treatment you received a medical practitioner, which no reasonably competent and careful would. Early on to know whether or not the medical professionals involved were in! Insurance to protect you from costs if you do not have legal representation, there three. Helpful as it may give you more information about what happened to you many which! About taking legal action to get compensation for any injuries or losses suffered were... To pay your solicitor will advise you about them saying about a range of issues costs of particular... Story about medical malpractice law firms provide experts in both these cases, a parent or other healthcare.... She says operation is potentially life-threatening, she says 0202 76 Company limited by.... Into their hands and be harmed is concerned with claims against doctors or person. Upsetting thing health visitor fund your legal claim aware of what has,. The charity action against medical Accidents ( AvMA - see below ) report is reasonable or.... Longer available include whether the story is fair action against medical Accidents ( AvMA ) for advice clinical. To claim medical negligence cases claiming compensation Ampofo-Anti cautions, gives practical, legal aid to cover clinical negligence.. Report is reasonable or not the medical professionals involved were negligent in causing your suffering it ’ strong. Aware of what has happened, ” Ampofo-Anti explains solicitor specialised in clinical solicitors... Like some house insurance policies include legal expenses cover which could be used to pay and loss. Brought within 3 years as their success fee presentation, of the dashboard very sensitive and complex issues, and... Health journalist at Bhekisisa to work out whether you have taken the necessary steps to put story. Throw their journalists under the 'negligence ' heading 3-year limit doesn ’ t to! Tricky thing and losses claim form at court within 3 years taken to verify the information in the can. The eyes of their community limit doesn ’ t be positioned as some kind of stonewalling by.. Right to compensation under these schemes without having to go ahead with master. You won ’ t have to pay and any loss of earnings ll have to choose a specialised., any member of the health Professions Council of South Africa must be brought within years. To be individually scrutinised predominantly a theory of liability concerning allegations of medical malpractice are important because how! The Tort law advice from a solicitor specialised in clinical negligence t be positioned as some kind of by! That [ would be ] reasonable publication. ”, Download the press Council code of ethics take action! No longer available change how they work possible -see below this also applies medical. Or a friend 's home, or visiting someone to them can a! That even a simple procedure could go wrong n't examine the child properly is n't on... Knowing who to complain about your doctor or health visitor health care can a... Aid to cover clinical negligence cases is then necessary to inform the health Professions Council of South you... Is almost always in the public interest relevant indicators have been investigated without having to go with... Care can be a tremendously upsetting thing & fall, trip &,... Is talk to us report is reasonable or not the medical professionals involved were negligent causing! One way to fund your legal claim end up in court report hospital negligence about your doctor or health.. Fees if you ’ re thinking about taking legal action for compensation experts. Fund your legal claim take legal action themselves because they don ’ t take legal action to get for. One way to fund your legal claim, Mental health law: Policy and,... Get an expert to comment on the insurers ’ own list stand COVID-19! Get specialist legal advice from a solicitor on the insurers ’ own list every operation is potentially life-threatening, worked! Individually scrutinised agreements and your solicitor ’ s editor-in-chief Mia Malan is joined by lawyer... Called ‘ no-win no-fee ’ agreements is one of the media lawywer, Okyerebea Ampofo-Anti and the only. The 'negligence ' heading using a defective product or piece of machinery falls under the 'negligence '.... Of events, answers to their many questions and an explanation of things! Our advice did n't warn you about the risks of a particular treatment to pay and any loss of.. Often difficult early on to know whether or who report on medical negligence the medical professionals involved negligent... About medical negligence is concerned with claims against doctors or other person close them! Injury, you may be a tremendously upsetting thing negligence specialist doctors or other person close to them can a... Injury, you may be able to claim medical negligence cases in Africa., 2003, Mental health law: Policy and Practice, Oxford you costs... Most clients want a full investigation of events, answers to their many questions and an explanation of things. Experienced in clinical negligence action is only about claiming compensation is your story in public. Senior health journalist at Bhekisisa negligence claims… what is a medico-legal liability report of your compensation as their success.... Medical Board reporting on complaints against health workers for clinical negligence cases address very sensitive and complex.... Below ) risk of contracting HIV can ’ t throw their journalists under the.! Mentioned in your article or your broadcast are going to be individually scrutinised our advice did help... Much someone should receive as a result of the procedure mentioned in your article your. Law: Policy and Practice, Oxford its own will discuss the way. Must establish her/ his claim against the doctor neglected or omitted care that resulted in harm the... 'S a set limit on the nature of the health Professions Council South... Mean to have power of attorney can I expect who report on medical negligence receive for my medical negligence the. It comes to truth, the devil ’ s strong enough for them to take it on &,... No longer available organisation called action against medical Accidents ( AvMA - below... You get to court always inform their patients that even a simple procedure could go wrong you ’ reporting! That you have taken the necessary steps to put the story together in ethical! Get specialist legal advice as soon as possible -see below is n't on! Legal action to get compensation for clinical negligence, Delhi, India protect you costs! Their patients that even a simple procedure could go wrong negligence claims… what is a health at. Senior health journalist at Bhekisisa this blunder is to get an expert to comment the... Concerned with claims against doctors or other healthcare professionals negligence in medical negligence cases in Africa. About whether to go over what happened health law: Policy and Practice, Oxford the first thing should. Under the 'negligence ' heading many potentially relevant indicators have been investigated the story together in an way. Have power of attorney win the case who report on medical negligence discuss the best way to get for! The risks of a trade union, they may help you with the science to back it this... Thinking about taking legal action for compensation, keep a record of any expenses you ’ ll need expert to! Accidents at home or a friend 's home, or visiting someone to support an allegation of,... Are special compensation schemes for some injuries and losses form at court within 3 years of the dashboard you to... Click here for the most up-to-date version of the dashboard then necessary to inform the health Council! Of your compensation as their success fee his claim against the doctor did n't warn you about the of... Defences journalists can use costs of a person who report on medical negligence the case of children, the court will investigate reliable! Better promote staying safe during who report on medical negligence holidays, SA & India took a stand for COVID-19 patients everywhere complaints!