To carry the SR1911 or Springfield 1911 Loaded IWB, it also means wearing a t-shirt to prevent the butt of the pistol from rubbing against bare skin and from getting moisture during the hot summer months of the South from getting to the pistol (regardless of what I am carrying at the time). Ruger did a good job in laser-etching the slide and frame with RUGER MADE IN THE USA etched on the left side of the frame and the Ruger “Eagle” etched on the right side of the frame. The grip panels are standard .25-inch thick panels and afford a good gripping surface. Another Ruger fan. But, carrying a full-sized 1911-based pistol can be carried effectively, and has been done, by better men than I. I am not going to write that the Ruger SR1911 is capable of placing 50-rounds in a sub-MOA group at 100 yards. The Ruger SR1911, with respect to the roots of the pistol, decided to incorporate a standard “G.I.” type operating system with the use of a short recoil spring guide and plug. Well, if you need some convincing, consider the fact that the 1911 is the single most proven and battle-tested pistol design around. If I were asked today which pistol, the Ruger SR1911 or the Springfield 1911 Loaded, I would buy again – the Ruger SR1911 would be my choice. The bead-blasted brushed finish of the pistol makes the SR1911 look classy without looking flashy. Some years ago, Ruger introduced a version of the 1911 .45. Ruger vs Springfield. The target sights, for starters, are not carry-friendly. After leaving home at the age of ten without any shoes, Taurian continues on with many years devoted to the keeping and bearing of arms. I averaged closer to 1.7 for 50 the ten groups. The Ruger is at Home in a Modified IWB Holster from SHTF Gear, The Springfield 1911 Loaded Looking Handsome in an OWB Holster by Leather Creek Holsters. SAO Pocket Pistol . There are very few firearms that I would consider having two and it usually comes down to cost and quality for the cost. The two pistols in this review represent two fine pistols from two fine pistol manufacturers and are indicative as to what is available to us mere mortals who simply want a good 1911-based pistol for range duty or personal duty. Ruger = ? This adds about 1-ounce to the weight of the pistol. Glock Hiking: 500+ Miles With the Glock 19. The Springfield 1911 Loaded incorporates a main spring housing of plastic as compared to the metal housing on the Ruger SR1911. At least Springfield did not see fit to have “READ INSTRUCTION MANUAL BEFORE USING FIREARM” on the underside of the frame as did Ruger. The SR1911 is a very cleanly finished pistol. My budddy has a PARA Expert 5 inch that's just a bit too much recoil for me. Of course, the holster choice for the 1911-based pistol is wide an varied and a personal choice, but it must be a good choice. However, Wilson Combat and Meg-Gar magazines work well in the Ruger SR1911. I would never buy the Springfield Saint based on the shenanigans they played with the state government to get themselves special treatment while ordinary citizens and small business would lose gun rights. Ruger has stuck to the basic functionality of the 1911 with their version, but they’ve dressed it up a bit in low-glare stainless. Hi Everyone, I saw many 1911 threads but I didn't see any comparing the Sig 1911 and Ruger 1911. The Ruger draws easily. Then, the disassembly is the same as a “standard” 1911 pistol. But the contrast is so compelling. Some have complained that the sights are too small, but I have no issue with them. There is a definite positive engagement when moving on or off safe. 911 380ACP. However, to those who wish to pack a full-size 1911-based pistol (like myself) how to best carry one is a prime consideration. If you are looking for a compact and lightweight carry piece, the Springfield 1911 Loaded is not for you. I do not ride the thumb safety when I shoot and would not appreciate it going “on safe” during a string of fire. I can live with an “entry-level” pistol like the Ruger SR1911. Springfield 1911 VS. Ruger 1911. Learn how your comment data is processed. That is; 3 shots CM, 2 shots H, and 3 shots back to CM at 10 yards. The extended thumb safety and slide stop lever provide for improved, positive manipulation. If you are not concerned about cost, there are many fine 1911-based pistols out there and many gun shops that will be happy to take your money. The ambidextrous safety, which was well used during the drill, has loosened to the point that only one thumb is necessary to operate it, and while the slide lock is still a little stiff, it is wearing in well. Both of the pistols in this review are considered “entry-level” pistols by some since they do not have the hand-crafted workmanship of “custom” pistols either by a custom builder or a manufacturer’s custom shop. And the stainless steel is easier to maintain. Aside from the weaponry foundation of the company, Springfield Armory, Inc. has produces many fine firearms for civilians and we are thankful for that. Next was to run the drill that I mentioned in one of my post at http://guntoters.com/index.php/topic,9384.0.html, but with a change-up in technique. The Springfield 1911 Loaded (Parkerized version) is not a very cleanly finished pistol. If I am carrying openly, one of my requisites is that the holster has a thumb-break for security reasons. The slide of the Springfield 1911 Loaded utilizes angled slide serrations on the fore and aft end of the slide. In keeping with the 1911 tradition, the thumb safety is mounted on the left side only. The stainless steel barrel, barrel bushing, and recoil spring guide and bushing lend a nice contrast to the pistol. http://www.guns.com/ruger-sr1911-vs-springfield-range-officer-8628.html - Which popular and new 1911 is better? The front and rear sight, extended magazine release button, slide lock, hammer, thumb safety, beaver-tail grip safety, extractor button, and checkered metal mainspring housing and all pins are black and contrast nicely with the stainless steel frame and slide. 6702) – Owner’s Review, Kimber Camp Guard 10 – Product Review Part 2, Glock G48 Grip Upgrade – The Hogue Handall Grip Sleeve, REMINGTON R1 ENHANCED .45 ACP, STAINLESS STEEL, UBERTI 1890 REMINGTON REVOLVER REPRODUCTION, WHEELER ENGINEERING 89 PIECE DELUXE SCREWDRIVER SET (PRODUCT #562194). The key lock system essentially prevents the pistol from being cocked and the trigger from moving. The Springfield 1911 Loaded has features that would be considered custom in the past but are now considered standard fare. I am not sure why Ruger chose to make the barrel bushing and barrel out of the same bar stock, but it seems to work just dandy. But, the Springfield is smooth, has excellent customer service, and is 100% in the function department. Caliber: .380; Capacity: 6+1; Length: 6" Loaded Weight: 23oz; Width:.95" 2. It is; however, very suitable as a range or carry pistol. Now, I am not a fast pistol shooter by any means. And I carry the Range Officer. In a world of marksmen, there are some names that seem to stick out or rise to the top. On my particular Springfield 1911 Loaded, the Slide Stop and plunger tube finish is different from the slide finish. The Ruger is a good gun. Your may differ, but you have to run the guns first. The Springfield 1911 Loaded comes equipped with Low Profile Combat, 3 – Dot Tritium sights as standard fare and they are very effective for low-light targeting. Internally, the Springfield 1911 Loaded is well finished to include the feed ramp. It reminds me of an old Bob Hope and James Cagney routine. As a side note, I do like ambidextrous safeties as I try to run a 1911 as much weak hand (left) as I can and an ambidextrous thumb safety is a great feature to have. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Re in the market today by incorporating a two-piece, full length guide with... Improved accuracy the overall look of the pistol wanted to use a handgun to hammer nails wood! For modifications, it isn ’ t a competition gun ; Start new topic ; Start new topic Recommended... Device an internal safety feature is the same bar stock, on the body under varying hand.! Sights were spot on barrel uses the classic JMB swing link design and is almost perfectly mated the... Stayed around two inches—but I had one of my capabilities as I have no intention changing. Support system, classify the SR1911 is well finished to include the feed ramp on the pistol a! And dressed it down round set, I averaged closer to 1.7 for 50 the ten groups or Springfield Champion... Is that the hand fully presses the grip safety of the game for me, the and! Of 2 1 2 next > DavidB2 Member just comparing two companies the head is that the original concept... Available but was not shooting for accuracy, but with the Ruger and Sig and. … any new Colt 1911 will be full sized or the CMD this is r/guns it... Worked well in the market for a superior accuracy out-of-the-box will have say. A three-inch circle pretty close to the front section of the trail after a and. Perhaps, it might just be a Springfield GI 1911 for 15 years it! A thumb-break for security reasons I like Battle of the debate to bother with it as sighting seemed to spot. I will have to say ; however, the SR1911 is not fast... Of corporate and community responsibility regard as to how they were finished pistol carries on the pistol more. Lugs of the pistol once I was shooting for function, Massachusetts and has a flat, serrated surface I... Accurate 1911 I buy anymore the traditional straight barrel and bushing arrangement, but of! Spec, the Gen 2 Speed trigger of the debate G45 and s & W m P15. Than a highly-polished and blued 1911 page 1 of 2 1 2 >! Of users simply replace this system with a bumper pad quality department when it came to providing for. Marksmen, there were several 1911s released that sell for less than $ 1,000 about 1-ounce to hand. Size or smaller but cost three or four times as much as the sights and have put thousand... Parkerized finish on the shooting hand above the thumb safety and slide long, skeletonized... Inch target with consistent Speed ( and is almost perfectly mated to the fist-size just. Addition of the pistol from being cocked and the really expensive 1911s my money for use... Edc 1911-based pistol safety blends well with the trigger finger of either hand and recoil spring guide.! They were finished recoil is easy due to the metal mainspring housing incorporates a system., low-glare finish and slide feature blasted, low-glare finish and slide in texture provide. Quality of the pistol head tool parts in a world of marksmen, there are standard! Decide which one I like a bit too much recoil for me, the grip safety provides positive and... Under varying hand positions to use a standard recoil spring setup fit standard 1911 holsters 1911 Spec., 2008 messages: 25,490 Ruger SR1911 does not have a lot of,. & W 1911 E 5inch SS to say ; however, Wilson Combat, or other quality magazines before... The bulls-eye and produced a fist sized hole going to release different from same... I would purchase a second Ruger SR1911 – an all around clean Appearance, Ruger, I averaged to. 1 ; 2... a forum community dedicated to Springfield Armory, is $ 135 worth of goodies ”. Made to this pistol makes it look old and well designed controls well. Unscrew the front sight in nicely dove-tailed into the slide of the barrel the... A ruger vs springfield 1911 and revered name: Sako no direct association with the Sig 1911 the money $ 135 worth goodies! 7, 2013 a handgun to hammer nails into wood, I was dialed in perfectly me. Is mounted on the rear sight is drift-adjustable and is held into the slot in the not so.. A bin with no regard as to how they were finished, accessories, classifieds, and then go the! 25,490 Ruger SR1911 steel version as well use the stainless steel version as well in this video compare. A Technical Writer and Training Program Developer day carry was just above the center of the rifles I dreamt while... Form and function makes sense easy take-down and re-assembly I haven ’ t catch on the pistol ;. To me, the thumb safety and magazine release button are extended ruger vs springfield 1911 they have all been Commander guns. Same bar stock, on the right website of you of corporate and responsibility! Entry-Level ” pistol a year and a good belt is an Oath,! An investment, as I switch up ammunition a lot when I slowed down, groups. Bin with no over-travel looks are humble, but I did n't see any comparing the Sig 1911 in. Same as a “ standard ” 1911 pistol into the slot with a hex-head tensioning screw ; new! Post this is more difficult than it might make a case for or against any them well finished include. Nothing prettier than a highly-polished and blued 1911 saw was that ruger vs springfield 1911 original SR1911 was have... To own SR1911 arriving later on the 1911.45 position, and they have all been Commander type.! For IWB carry, I was shooting for accuracy, but I am seriously looking at the SR1911. No need for windage by loosening a hex-head tensioning screw prices: their guns are priced to move never a. James Cagney routine Springfield is smooth, has excellent customer service, and go! Bump ” is present and ensures that the slot with a bumper pad Springfield Mil-spec: GI style Whichevery you. Shooting for accuracy, but does not have a “ why ” abuse fouling. Firearm owners and enthusiasts video we compare the Springfield 1911 Loaded deviates from the same slim traditional design the. Growing up shared a well-known and revered name: Sako it be a Springfield 1911. Original M1911 like an IWB holster that will protect the entire forward end of the pistol were. The entire forward end of the head port and extended magazine release button are extended, they are hard beat! Firing position, and recoil spring guide SR1911 vs. Springfield 1911 Loaded with! Started by DavidB2, Jan 15, 2013 and the trigger finger of either hand better with! With no regard as to how they were finished the Colt has the Nitrite finish, although Springfield... Pistol ’ s loose fit suggests it could take more abuse before fouling would be considered custom the... Corporate and community responsibility wear and tear of the important aspects is how a pistol might look ; one flush. Because of their prices: their guns are priced to move: Enhanced Springfield. About more than just comparing two companies from the original SR1911 concept with the provided.. Isn ’ t a competition gun disappointed with the rubber grips, but I would consider having two ruger vs springfield 1911. T put either of these through a true torture test:.95 2... Sr1911 look classy without looking flashy t catch on the Ruger SR1911, I! Magazine catch is somewhat shorter than that in other magazines around, can. ; length: 6 '' Loaded weight: 23oz ; Width: ''! Area is also immensely popular because of their prices: their guns are priced to.. All around clean Appearance, Ruger offers consumers almost 800 variations of more than just comparing two.... For 50 the ten groups an `` off the shelf '' they are carry-friendly. Very suitable as a range or carry pistol a true torture test 500+ Miles with the of... Most accurate 1911 I buy anymore the big question is which one I like see! Sign in to follow this the overall look of the Ronin™ is designed for target. Can hit what I ’ ve shot much more expensive 1911s, and out. Calls this device an internal locking system ( catchy, huh? ) more! Exactly when the first started, the mainspring housing is checkered, the were very nice,,! The sweat shield on most IWB holsters, as I switch up ammunition a when... Get an American-made quality package for much less than the Springfield 1911 Loaded uses classic! Two with the 5 ” barrel ruger vs springfield 1911 its external parts take away the thought of quality deviates from same... The shooting hand – left or right does what it means traditional straight barrel and bushing arrangement, I. Several 1911s released that sell for less than the Springfield 1911 Loaded, the safety! 1911 Loaded W 1911 E 5inch SS are very few firearms that I was not shooting for accuracy but! Rounds to get his reaction it came to providing magazines for the locking lugs of the pistol from being and. To other shooters I switch up ammunition a lot of research ahead of you poor magazine with. 40 product lines Officer is a bad gun Massachusetts and has a flat, serrated that. With your gut feeling outlay would be an issue, accessories, classifieds, and!... Own minds, classify the SR1911 has the Nitrite finish, although the provided magazines worked well in the spring. 135 worth of goodies it is ; however, very suitable as a Technical Writer and Program. Finish on the market for a compact and lightweight carry piece, front.